A tribunal judge has received a formal warning following an investigation into comments she allegedly made about the Roma community, which were found to constitute misconduct.
Tribunal judge Fozia Rizvi was the subject of a complaint from a fellow tribunal member, who alleged that she had made disparaging generalisations about the Roma community during discussions before a hearing.
Rizvi denied making the comments and rejected any suggestion that she held prejudicial views. In her response, she highlighted her extensive legal career, stating that she had never previously faced complaints involving racism or prejudice. She also referred to her work supporting minority groups.
The judge suggested that the complaint had been made in bad faith but declined to provide further details when invited to explain the basis for that allegation.
Following an investigation, the Judicial Conduct Investigations Office (JCIO) concluded that Rizvi had made the comments. Her allegation that the complaint had been submitted in bad faith was rejected and considered an aggravating factor in assessing her conduct.
The JCIO referred to the Guide to Judicial Conduct, which emphasises that judicial office-holders should demonstrate courtesy, patience and tolerance while respecting the dignity of everyone involved in legal proceedings. It also states that judges must avoid any appearance of bias or prejudice, including on grounds of race, religion, national origin and other protected characteristics.
Despite finding that the comments amounted to misconduct, the Lady Chief Justice and Lord Chancellor considered the mitigating circumstances presented by Rizvi, including her demonstrated commitment to equality and support for minority groups. They concluded that the conduct did not indicate fundamentally racist views.
Nevertheless, they considered the nature of the remarks sufficiently serious to justify a formal warning rather than formal advice.
The decision highlights the importance of maintaining impartiality, professional standards and public confidence in the judiciary. Judicial office-holders are expected to uphold principles of fairness, dignity and equality, both inside and outside the courtroom.
Under the judicial disciplinary framework, sanctions for misconduct are arranged in increasing order of severity: formal advice, formal warning, reprimand and removal from office.